Top 5 bad welds – how to spot them
Updated: Jun 17, 2022
By Ed West, Custom Welder Team Lead
See how to spot a bad weld when reviewing your next project for quality
With 30+ years of experience and having gone through training to receive the American Welding Society (AWS) Welder Certification in the past, I recently moved into managing our welding team at the Lexington site.
I ensure that I do continuous training with the team on metal inert gas (MIG) welding, which is often used when speed is required. I also do quite a bit of tungsten inert gas (TIG) welding, which takes longer but man, does it look better and hold well for complex projects.
I see welding as an art form; and everyone I hire thinks so too.
Sometimes customers will come to us to fix metal pieces after a safety issue has come to the surface. I always want customers to know proactively how to spot a bad weld rather than waiting for something to happen.
With porosity, the welder’s mistake is not enough gas used or wind overhead hitting the metal. It creates a poor cosmetic finish and weakens durability because the material hasn’t fully bonded.
The weld is too hot so it actually cuts into the metal weakening the material, itself. This creates structural integrity issues and cracks. While I won’t get into the nitty gritty, the fabricator details how far is too far.
3. Cold weld
Cold welding happens when the weld voltage isn’t set to the right temperature, and the weld is laid on top of the metal. It won’t hold with the incomplete fusion. This will be very obvious with inspection.
4. End Craters/Cracks
End craters and crack occur when the welder stops too early, especially at the corners. The welder should be wrapping the weld and go from the two opposite sides to meet them. (S)he should overlay slightly with the last beads. You are going to see structural issues over time if you don’t do this right, but it may not be immediately.
You can see the little balls of metal all over the place. Cosmetically, It does not look good and shows lack of pride in the work piece.
These ruin the cosmetic finish of your piece. It’s like seeing a beautiful face with pimples all over it.
It can also throw off the measurements of the rest of the project, especially if it’s part of the base. I always start by using my scraper.
Then, I used my flat disk to finish cleaning it off for a smooth surface.
Rarely will I use spatter spray because it can enter the weld joint and cause problems with weld penetration, or even create more spatter. But, In tight corners it Is required.
More about the difference in welds
MIG welding is often used when speed is required. When performed well, MIG welds aren’t typically as clean as TIG welds, but the increased efficiency can be beneficial.
TIG welding uses a tungsten electrode to produce a weld rather than a consumable wire. It allows for the greatest operational control relative to MIG welding and creates stronger welds. TIG welding is more complex, slower and difficult to learn.
Stainless steel is a common working metal for TIG welding as is aluminum, magnesium and copper.
While customers can feel the durability and cosmetic finish, it’s a process to get there and an art form to do it well no matter the type of welding.
While our location uses traditional welding equipment, our Sidney, Ohio location uses OTC welding equipment. My counterpart, Mark Gibson, at the Sidney, Ohio factory is an AWS Certified Weld Inspector and has a team of welders. He chose welding equipment that is known for its capabilities with welding aluminum. This welding machine was chosen because:
Its reduction of human error by being able to program the heat specifications for repeated use
its ability to do aluminum welding, spatter-free & aesthetics similar to TIG welding
our focus on bringing in innovative technology (ability to connect robotics into it in the future)
having a research center near the Sidney, Ohio site. We recently did a full-day training at the Sidney site to reinforce the capability as part of our ongoing training program